A fresh storm hit X (formerly Twitter) after Hotmail co-founder Sabeer Bhatia raised a tough question — why calling out issues like women’s safety or poor economic data in India is often seen as “anti-national”? His post triggered massive online debate.
Harsh Goenka’s Counter Punch
Soon after, businessman Harsh Goenka responded strongly. He questioned why someone living abroad should comment on India’s internal matters. The post gained traction fast, with many agreeing that those who live, vote, and work in India are the ones who are driving real change — not people watching from a distance.
India vs Abroad: The Old Divide Returns
The July 2025 exchange brought back a familiar debate: should NRIs speak about Indian issues, or should this be left to those on the ground? Bhatia believes calling out hard truths is important. But many argue that change should come from within — by those who are part of the system every day.
Not Bhatia’s First Controversy
This isn’t new for Bhatia. He had earlier criticized India for celebrating its economic rise while millions still live in poverty. Many felt he ignored the progress made by everyday citizens and small businesses who are working hard despite the odds.
Air India Crash Comment Sparks More Anger
Things escalated further when Bhatia called public mourning after the tragic Air India crash in Ahmedabad “fake emotions.” His words angered many who found the remark insensitive. He later clarified, saying his intention was to demand accountability, not disrespect the grief.
Mohandas Pai Joins In
Former Infosys CFO Mohandas Pai also stepped in, saying that those who’ve left India shouldn’t throw stones at it from abroad. He hinted that criticism is easier when you’re not on the ground building or fixing things.
Who Gets to Speak for India?
The larger question remains — who truly represents India’s voice? Is it only those living in the country, or can global citizens be part of the conversation too?
While one side talks about holding the system accountable, the other emphasizes action, not opinion. What’s clear is that patriotism today is deeply personal — whether you stay or leave, speak up or build quietly — everyone’s voice reflects their version of care.
